RALEIGH, N.C. — One of the seven members of the North Carolina Utilities Commission is leaving the panel that sets electric, natural gas and water rates across the state. State Treasurer Brad Briner said Wednesday, Nov. 18, that Commissioner Donald van der Vaart has resigned and that his last day on the panel will be Dec. 31, with the departure official on Jan. 1, 2027.
The announcement came two days after van der Vaart broke in part with the majority on the commission’s big Duke Energy decision, which raised rates for Duke Energy Progress and created a separate pricing structure for very large data center customers. He will keep serving through the end of December.
Where he disagreed
In his written dissent, van der Vaart said he agreed with parts of the order, including a separate schedule for data centers drawing 50 megawatts or more and the rule that a customer pays for equipment built only for it. His main objection was who covers the cost of new power plants if the data centers that prompted them shut down or move away.
He pointed out that the plants are designed to run for about 35 years while the data center contracts last 15. In an illustration included in the order, a data center using 500 megawatts that left after 15 years would owe an exit charge of about $338 million, which he calculated would cover only around half the plant investment still unpaid at that point.
He also opposed the 9.8% return on equity the commission granted Duke, arguing it did not match the risk the order moves from the company onto customers. Duke has signed contracts for deals covering roughly 6.7 gigawatts of added demand from big customers on its Carolinas systems since March 2024, and nearly all of it comes from data centers.
Who picks his replacement
Briner named van der Vaart to the commission in April 2025 after legislators passed a law handing the treasurer one seat the governor used to fill. Gov. Josh Stein is still challenging that shift in a case that the state Supreme Court is now weighing.
Van der Vaart once ran two state agencies, the Department of Environmental Quality and the Office of Administrative Hearings. He is an engineer and attorney who has served on the Environmental Protection Agency’s Scientific Advisory Board. Briner said he will name a new commissioner in the coming days and weeks.
Section: More Asheville NC politics news
Filed under: Asheville NC Politics News